If you remove uncomfortable words from literature, you remove the heart of the entire reason for their use. Mark Twain was a masterful wordsmith who chose his words carefully, and he didn’t live in a vacuum, he understood the negative charge the N-word carried, even back then. Inclusion of the dehumanizing N-word sharply contrasts the reality of who Jim actually was, a kind, caring, noble human being, of higher character than most of the self-important whites he and Huck encountered. That one despicable word spoke volumes, both about those using it, how they used it and the reason they used it, as well as how Jim reacted to the use of it during different interactions, weighted by the motives and actions of the one using that word.
Despots know, and use the brutal tactic of labelling to conquer and rule, whether thousands of years ago or today, its effectiveness hasn’t changed, it still works. In order to justify mistreatment and/or extermination of a certain group, first you must dehumanize the members of that group. How better to depict that process than to live through it with a member of a group undergoing such long-term dehumanization? There will never be only the “bad guy’s” side or the “good guy’s” side, there are two sides, both with their own perspectives, rationalizations and goals. To truly understand the entire argument, both sides and the underlying motives driving their opinions and conclusions must be presented and explored.
The emotional interplay of actors is true of all labelling of either individual persons or whole groups for the purpose of marginalization. Such labelling is in wide use today, just as it was when Huckleberry Finn was written. It’s not going away. It’s a regrettable human failing to attempt to relegate someone else to the lowly position of being less so you can assume the vaulted position of being more, at least in your own eyes and perhaps the eyes of your group. It doesn’t work, at least not for long, it never has. Yes, the popular person or group to label may change, but the poisonous spirit behind the use of labelling others is alive and well.
Outside of our homes and churches, what better place than in the school room, through the use of great literature, to educate children on both the crippling power and deadly danger of choosing to label others? What better way to teach children how unfair, demeaning and cruel it is than to have them live through it themselves through the eyes of someone experiencing dehumanization?
Bullying is an epidemic in schools. Analyzing all the harmful aspects of dehumanization by use of slurs of all kinds, and the crushing results such labelling has on its victim(s), seems a critical topic to explore in the classroom. If you care about the next generation, don’t take the expeditious and therefore cowardly way out by refusing to acknowledge such evils exist, dedicate yourself to teaching our children why something is wrong. Erasing words from a book won’t erase from any heart the poison those words reveal, only education and understanding can do that.
The world is filled with unpleasantness, injustice, evil and downright horror, we must teach our children how to counter and defend against those things, no matter what form they may take, in order to assume their rightful places as adults, unafraid of the future, no matter what they may encounter. We, those whose duty it is to prepare the next generation to take over control from us, can sleep easy, if we have done that duty to the best of our abilities. Mark Twain understood the importance of that pivotal fact. Do we?
macjam47 said:
Excellent post!
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
Thank you so much! 🙂
LikeLike
debyfredericks said:
This book is so often challenged, and I wonder… What do those who challenge it actually hope to prevent? Is it the pain of the “N-word,” or the risk that children may learn and become wiser as they feel the pain of that word along with Jim?
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
That’s an astute observation! Empathy for “the other” seems to be a dying quality, the very attribute that drove us to fight to end racism. How can you care for someone if you can’t identify with them? Thank you for your comment.
LikeLiked by 1 person
jhawker1969 said:
This is an excellent essay on our inane need to sanitize history. Those of us who write historical fiction understand that to be politically correct when writing about the past is to be dishonest with your readers. P.C. has no business in historical fiction. The past is the past, warts and all. Cleaning up the language of the time as well as the attitudes toward race, gender, religious affiliation, etc. is deceitful and hypocritical, and authors who do this should be horsewhipped.
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
Thank you! I agree with you. My first introduction to Huckleberry Finn was at the age of 9 or 10 but, even at that young age living in the South in a country area where the N-word was still in common use and the schools were still segregated, reading it sent a little shock of revulsion through me. I knew instinctively it was wrong to treat another human being that way. Of course, my mother’s fierce egalitarianism probably had something to do with my attitude.
The biggest injustice we do our children is assuming they’re incapable of understanding complex topics. They’re not stupid and we treat them as if they are at our own peril. One day they will lead, where they lead is largely determined by us.
LikeLike
delphini510 said:
How very clever to set off the vices and hatred from despots and bullies against
Huckleberry Finn book. Your article is so true today as it was before
and without good handling verbal cruelty causes untold pain.
I know of schools now that handle the problem of bullying so well that it is “not in” to be a bully. You have a much higher status among friends if you are helpful and
genuinely a good friend. It works.
Would be good if adults in work places could learn the same.😊 .
Thanks
Miriam
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
Thank you! It’s wonderful if some educators have discovered how to stop bullying, wouldn’t it be even more wonderful if that could spread nationwide?
LikeLike
V.M.Sang said:
How very true. Of course, the haters, those who wish to ‘exterminate’ the hated group will find another one if they succeed in their objective. Then another. Such is their insecurity.
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
Sadly, that’s all too true. Thank you for your comment.
LikeLike
Marilyn Armstrong said:
I completely agree. Absolutely 100%.
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
Thank you! Great to meet a kindred soul.
LikeLike
kethuprofumo said:
!!!!!!!!!!!!! Brilliant post!
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
Thank you! That’s a wonderful compliment.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Bette A. Stevens said:
Excellent article! Sharing…
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
Thank you! I’m so happy you like my article.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Bette A. Stevens said:
Reblogged this on Bette A. Stevens, Maine Author and commented:
Mark Twain knew what he was doing! Find out more in this must-read article. Excerpt: “Bullying is an epidemic in schools. Analyzing all the harmful aspects of dehumanization by use of slurs of all kinds, and the crushing results such labelling has on its victim(s), seems a critical topic to explore in the classroom. If you care about the next generation, don’t take the expeditious and therefore cowardly way out by refusing to acknowledge such evils exist, dedicate yourself to teaching our children why something is wrong. Erasing words from a book won’t erase from any heart the poison those words reveal, only education and understanding can do that…”
LikeLiked by 1 person
SFWhite said:
Thank you so much, I’m honored!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: Mark Twain’s Use Of The N-Word In Huckleberry Finn | Campbells World